Squarespace or Shopify? It's a question I get asked often as my time as a web designer and digital consultant. Both platforms are popular choices, particularly because they're very similar in terms of their ease of use. So, if you're here trying to figure out which platform would suit your business best, I'll make it really simple. The long and short of it is this…
If you have a primarily service-based business, go with Squarespace. If you're opening a full-blown e-commerce storefront, go with Shopify.
Of course, there are situations where the lines start to get a bit blurred. So let’s get into that, shall we?
1. Are you primarily service-based or product-based?
Shopify is built for e-commerce. Now, you might be thinking, "Well, I do plan to sell some products." Cool. But is that your main business? If you're primarily service-based but want to sell some products, Squarespace will get the job done. If you're only using maybe 10%, 20%, or even 30% of the e-commerce functionality, stick with Squarespace.
But if you're selling products, including digital products, and you're building a full-blown storefront where services account for maybe 10% to 20% of your business, Shopify is the better way to go.
And if you already know that you plan to shift your business model primarily from service-based to e-commerce-based, it makes sense to consider Shopify from the beginning.
2. What if you want to sell your services online as a product?
Confused? Here’s an example. I once had a client who launched her personal brand and consulting business with a one-page website. The website positioned her and made everything she needed possible to sell her consulting services. Alongside the website, I guided her through developing a media kit, which we incorporated into her overall digital and website strategy.
It worked so well that she outgrew her one-page website really quickly.
She reached a point where she didn't want to stop and answer a bunch of queries, go back and forth with emails, send information, and follow up. She wanted to productize her services. If you're very clear on your offerings and they don't shift frequently, or you don't want to do a lot of custom quotes, you can productize your services and go the e-commerce route.
And that can be done on both Squarespace and Shopify.
In her unique situation, she chose Shopify because of the backend tools available for currency conversion. It made things a lot easier for her.
However, if that isn't important to you, you can also productize your service-based business using Squarespace's e-commerce features. Squarespace allows you to sell services as products, with checkout and payment capabilities. They also now have the option to purchase your service like an ordinary checkout process, without the client having to pay in full, you can give your clients the option to make a deposit and during checkout there is also a capture form to capture pertinent information.
So this is where the lines start to get blurred. It really boils down to what's important to you and your business.
3. You're not just choosing a platform. You're choosing a system that supports your business.
Before recommending a platform, I need to understand your business model, what you're trying to sell, who you're trying to sell to, and ultimately, your goals for your business and website.
If you're still figuring out your business model or don't have all your content and branding together, I recommend launching with a one-page website and growing from there as your brand becomes more established. And yes, both Squarespace and Shopify allow you to build a website yourself. So what are you paying for when you hire a professional?
You're paying for expertise.
Someone who knows the ropes can guide you and help you get to the finish line faster than you bumping around and figuring it out yourself. ‘Cause let’s be real, you’re a serious business owner, and time is money. And it's not just the platform. It's the strategy, marketing, and messaging guidance behind building your website.
At From Basic to Branded, our goal is to help clients have systems that support them. Your website should be supporting you and removing a lot of the administrative work that's time-consuming.
Quite frankly, when you're caught up with admin, you aren't making money. Admin supports the business, but when you're constantly going back and forth, you're taking time away from marketing.
Marketing pulls people into your ecosystem, nurtures them, and gets them to check out and pay the dollars.
We're trying to be efficient with our businesses, because the more efficient we can be, the more profitable we can become. If you're still unsure which platform is best for your business, book a consultation. I can help guide you toward the right solution.
Working With Basic to Branded
At From Basic to Branded, I've worked with Squarespace for nearly a decade, helping businesses develop websites that bring together brand strategy, thoughtful design, and practical digital systems.
As a Squarespace Circle Partner, I combine that experience with access to platform resources, professional education, and an international community of web designers.
My focus isn't simply on getting your website published. It's on creating a digital foundation that is functional, manageable, and aligned with where your business is going.
Planning a new Squarespace website or considering a redesign?
Book a Consultation to discuss what your business needs.
Let’s Work Together
Ready to stop treating your website and brand assets like a one-time project, and start treating them like the intentional, revenue-supporting system they’re meant to be?
Book a Website Strategy Consultation or a Clarity Call to map out the next phase of your book launch and brand growth.
Ask about white-label partnerships if you are a leading creative agency seeking a trusted creative director.
Or simply reach out and let’s talk through what strategic support looks like for your stage of business — from refining your messaging and structure to designing a website that actually supports how you sell and grow.
You don’t have to figure out your next step on your own. But you do have to take the first step toward building something that truly supports you.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Answer: Because your website isn’t just about it existing, you have a website but is it working. If it hasn’t been optimized, updated, or reviewed in the past 3–6 months, chances are it’s no longer aligned with your business goals. A strategy session helps you refocus and turn your site into a tool again, not just a placeholder.
-
Answer: This isn’t a generic chat. We’ll review your current website, identify where it's falling flat, and discuss what needs to shift, whether it’s content, structure, visibility (SEO), or conversion flow. You’ll leave with clarity, recommendations, and a roadmap you can use.
-
Answer: Absolutely. Most of the time, you don’t need a full rebuild, you need a professional eye and some smart, intentional tweaks. This session helps you maximize what you already have and build a phased plan if a full redesign ever becomes necessary.
-
Answer: Yes, my support packages are built with sustainability in mind.
Whether it’s a quarterly check-in, a flexible refresh plan, or a lightweight retainer, we can find a rhythm that works for your business and budget. The goal is consistent alignment, not constant updates.
-
Answer: I hear this more often than you’d think. What makes this different is the focus on strategy and relationship. We don’t just build things, I ask questions, guide decisions, and help you maintain your investment.
And if something isn’t the right fit, I’ll tell you. No fluff, no pressure.
-
Answer: Of course, you can! However, the better question is: are you actually doing it? If not, there’s no shame in that. Most business owners don’t have the time, capacity, or clarity to make the most strategic edits. That’s where I come in, to partner with you and take that weight off your plate.